Free Shipping on Qualifying Orders Over $75! *Continental US Only*

Orders are Typically Shipped in 5 to 7 Business Days

Mild Sauces

Not every sauce needs to test your limits. This collection is built for people who want bold, layered flavor without the depths of a fiery inferno.

These are the mustard, BBQ, and mellow hot sauces you'll reach for every single day to liven up your eggs, wings, pasta, and more.

Of course, our mild sauces get the same TorchBearer love and attention. Start slathering them on anything in sight (especially Aunt Millie’s latest casserole creation).

Real fruits, real vegetables, and real peppers make up every small-batch of sauce made by real people in Pennsylvania; zero extracts and zero apologies.

Filter by

Sort by

Filter by

Oh My Garlic™ $6.79 $7.99

Bottle | 12 oz

Some Spice, No Sweat

Every sauce in this collection sits between Level 0 and Level 2 on our heat scale. That means warmth, not warfare.

Oh My Garlic is a creamy, all-natural garlic aioli at Level 0 without any heat at all. Seeing how it’s been one of our top sellers since 2011, that just goes to show that you don’t always need to melt your face off. Sometimes you just need some rich garlic flavor.

Everyday Sauce brings a slightly tangy blend of fruits and vegetables that works on just about everything.

Buffalo Wing delivers classic buffalo flavor built on our signature fruit and veggie base with just enough habanero kick to keep things interesting.

Flavor first. Always.

Flavor Everyone Can Handle

These are the bottles that stay on the table when company comes over. Cookouts, weeknight dinners, game day spreads; nobody gets left out, and nobody has to eat around the sauce.

From Honey Mustard to Pineapple Papaya BBQ, there's something here for every person at the table. All-natural ingredients, no weird stuff, and enough range to keep things from ever getting boring.

FAQs

What’s the point of a mild hot sauce?

Well, poor Aunt Millie can’t handle the heat, and she deserves flavor, too, right? A good flavorful mustard, BBQ, or mild hot sauce adds depth, sweetness, tang, or smokiness to whatever you're eating.

How do these sauces compare to your other hot sauces?

We’re well-known for our super hots as seen on Hot Ones. These mellow options sit at Level 0 to 2 on our heat scale, while celeb-sampled sauces like Garlic Reaper and Zombie Apocalypse live up at Level 8 and 9 (or even 10!).

We stay committed to all-natural ingredients and real peppers, regardless of the heat level.

I don’t really like spicy food. How mild are these sauces?

You're in the right place. A couple of these have nothing spicier than some ground black pepper while the rest top out at a gentle Level 2. You get all the flavor TorchBearer is known for, with warmth that stays well in the background.

Some of these mild sauces aren’t even hot sauces! Try one of our not-too-spicy mustards or tangy BBQs. Break open Psycho Curry for your next culinary experiment.

Generally, if our sauce comes in a small 5-oz bottle, it’s a hot sauce. If it’s in a big 12-oz bottle, it’s not a hot sauce.